MyAlgoGuru Help
Education Glossary Open the app
Chapter 5 of 5

Basis, carry and rollover

The gap between a future and its spot is mostly arithmetic. The part that is not arithmetic is the only part worth reading, and separating the two is the skill.

A future and its underlying are two prices for the same thing at different dates, so the gap between them is not a mystery — most of it is the cost of waiting.

Basis = futures price − spot price. It is the single most quoted and most over-interpreted number in the futures market, because it mixes together something mechanical and something informative, and almost nobody separates them before drawing a conclusion.

Most of the basis is carry

Hold the underlying for a month and you tie up capital, which has a financing cost. You also receive any dividends paid in that month. A future lets you have the exposure without the funding and without the dividends, so its fair price differs from spot by roughly:

financing cost for the remaining period − dividends expected in that period

That quantity is the cost of carry, and in normal conditions it accounts for nearly all of the basis. Which gives you the two structural facts that follow from it.

A future normally trades above spot, because financing usually outweighs dividends, and the premium is larger the further away expiry is.

The basis must converge to zero at expiry, because at settlement the future is the spot — there is no waiting left to pay for. This is not a tendency; it is a certainty enforced by the settlement mechanism.

futures spot 0 basis zero at expiry, always expiry
The convergence is structural, not a signal. The future sits above spot and the gap narrows as expiry approaches, because the gap is payment for a waiting period that keeps getting shorter. A long futures position therefore pays away this premium simply by the passage of time — the futures equivalent of theta, and a real cost of holding a long futures view over weeks that traders who think only in points routinely forget to count.

The part that is informative

Since most of the basis is carry, the readable part is the deviation from the carry-implied level — not the basis itself.

Compute roughly what carry says the basis should be, compare it against what the basis actually is, and the residual carries information:

A future at a bigger premium than carry justifies means there is more demand for long exposure through the future than arbitrage has eliminated. In practice this shows up when leveraged buyers are keen and there is some friction in the arbitrage.

A future at a discount to spot is the more interesting case, because carry says it should be at a premium. It generally indicates heavy demand for short exposure, or that holders of the underlying are hedging aggressively — the future is being sold hard enough to push it below fair value and keep it there.

The important discipline is the subtraction. Comparing today's raw basis against last week's raw basis conflates a change in sentiment with the simple fact that there are fewer days to expiry. The basis narrows every single day for purely mechanical reasons, and a reader who has not removed that drift will see a "deteriorating" signal every month, resetting every month, forever.

Rollover

In the last days of a series, participants who want to keep their exposure must close the expiring contract and open the next one. That migration is rollover, and the share of open interest that moves across is a genuine piece of information.

What it tells you: whether conviction is being carried forward or retired. A high proportion rolled means positions are being maintained — whatever the view was, it is still held. A low proportion means positions were simply closed out, and the exposure that existed this month will not exist next month.

Two cautions, both of which get ignored:

Rollover is direction-blind. It tells you exposure persisted; it does not tell you whose. Longs and shorts both roll, and a high rollover figure is equally consistent with conviction on either side. Pairing the rollover percentage with the price action during the roll period, and better with participant-category data, is what makes it readable.

Compare it against its own history. A rollover figure means nothing in isolation. The useful question is whether it is high or low relative to the recent average for that instrument, because the typical level differs by instrument and by period.

The practical bits

The front contract is not the only one. When you look at a futures chart, know which series it is. Stitched continuous series — the standard way to get a long history — paste together different contracts, and the joins are artificial price jumps. A strategy backtested on a stitched series has been tested partly on those joins, which is a real and frequently overlooked source of fictitious profit. If a strategy's edge concentrates near the rollover dates, suspect the stitching before you believe the edge.

Calendar spreads trade the basis directly. Long one expiry and short another is a position in the shape of the curve rather than in direction. It is lower-variance than an outright and it is not low-risk: the two legs have to be managed as a unit, and the chapter on per-leg risk applies with full force — a calendar with one leg closed is an outright position you did not intend to hold.

When you read order flow on an index, you are reading the front future. From the chapter on volume and delta: a spot index has no volume, so any flow display on it uses the front future as a proxy. Everything in this chapter is a reason that proxy is imperfect. The front future carries basis dynamics, rollover flows and a participant mix weighted towards hedgers and arbitrageurs — none of which is the index, and all of which is in the data you are reading.

What to take from this chapter

  • Basis = futures − spot, and most of it is cost of carry: financing minus expected dividends.
  • A future normally sits above spot and must converge to zero at expiry. That convergence is a real cost of holding a long futures view over time.
  • The readable signal is the deviation from the carry-implied basis, not the basis itself. Subtract the mechanical part first or you will see a false monthly cycle.
  • A future at a discount to spot is notable precisely because carry says it should be at a premium.
  • Rollover tells you whether exposure is being carried forward. It is direction-blind, and only meaningful against its own recent history.
  • Stitched continuous futures series contain artificial jumps at the joins. An edge concentrated near rollover dates is probably the stitching.
  • Calendar spreads trade the curve, not direction — and a calendar with one leg closed is an outright position.
  • Order flow shown on an index is the front future's flow, with all of this chapter's dynamics baked in.