MyAlgoGuru Help
Education Glossary Open the app
Chapter 4 of 5

Break-even: the move your edge has to clear

Costs do not reduce your profit. They raise the hit rate you need, and the arithmetic of how much is the most sobering calculation in this module.

There is a way of thinking about costs that makes them feel like a modest deduction, and a way that makes them feel like the constraint they actually are.

The modest version: "a round trip costs ₹70, so my ₹1,125 profit becomes ₹1,054."

The real version: "a round trip costs about one point per unit, my average winner is three points, so a third of my gross edge is gone before I have been right or wrong about anything."

Same arithmetic. Only the second one tells you whether the strategy is viable.

One number, assembled

From the previous three chapters, for a 75-unit position in an at-the-money weekly option at a premium of ₹120:

Component Per unit
Statutory and brokerage (chapter 1) ₹0.94
Spread crossed both ways (chapter 3) ₹0.10
Break-even move ₹1.04

That is the number to carry. The option must move 1.04 in your favour before you have earned one rupee — about 0.87% of the premium you put up.

Now hold that against what your strategy actually targets. If you are scalping for three or four points, you have just learned that a quarter to a third of your gross profit is cost. If you are swing-trading for thirty points, it is three percent and barely matters. The identical cost is decisive in one strategy and irrelevant in the other, and nothing about the fee schedule changed — only the size of the move you are trying to capture.

What costs actually do to your odds

Here is the calculation worth doing once properly, because it reframes everything.

Without costs, a strategy whose average win equals its average loss breaks even at a 50% hit rate. Add a cost of c per trade and the required hit rate becomes:

Break-even hit rate = (average loss + c) ÷ (average win + average loss)

Costs do not shave the edges off your returns. They move the bar you have to clear.

50% 70% 90% free trading: 50% your actual cost — 67% needed ₹1.04 per unit against a 3-point edge ₹0 ₹1.04 ₹2 ₹3 cost per unit, round trip
A three-point edge, and what costs do to the hit rate it needs. With no costs the strategy breaks even at 50%. At the real cost of ₹1.04 per unit it needs 67%. At a cost equal to the edge itself — three points, which is roughly what a far strike's spread alone can be — it needs 100%, meaning it cannot work at any skill level. Nothing about the strategy has changed along this line. Only the friction.

Fifty percent to sixty-seven percent is not a refinement. It is the difference between a plausible strategy and a very difficult one. A seventeen-point jump in required accuracy is far more than most traders can find by improving their rules, which is why cost reduction is usually the highest-return work available to a short-horizon trader — and why size, legs and re-entry frequency are strategic decisions rather than details.

The ratio to compute for every strategy you run

Divide the round-trip cost by the average gross win. That single fraction tells you where you stand:

Cost ÷ average win What it means
Under 5% Costs are a detail. Spend your attention elsewhere.
5% to 15% Real but workable. Worth one pass at size and order count.
15% to 33% Costs are now a primary design constraint, not a deduction.
Over 33% You are mostly trading to pay fees. Restructure or stop.

Three things move that ratio, in descending order of how much they help:

Make the move bigger. Doubling your target halves the ratio and costs you nothing but patience. It is the only lever with no downside other than fewer trades.

Trade fewer, larger positions. Flat ₹20 brokerage means one 750-unit trade costs a fraction of ten 75-unit trades, for identical exposure.

Remove orders. Every leg is two orders and every re-entry is a full round turn. A fourth leg on a structure doubles your brokerage — it had better be earning more than that.

Notice what is not on the list: finding a cheaper broker. Brokerage is one of six deductions and the statutory floor from chapter one is not negotiable by anybody.

How many round trips a day is too many

Turn the number around and it gives you a budget.

Illustrative

A 75-unit position, ₹1.04 per unit per round trip, so ₹78 per round trip.

If your account is ₹5,00,000 and you would like 2% a month, you need ₹10,000 a month, or roughly ₹500 a trading day.

At six round trips a day you are paying ₹468 in costs. Your gross would have to be ₹968 a day — nearly double the target — for the net to arrive.

At two round trips a day you pay ₹156, and need ₹656 gross.

At six trips you are working twice as hard for the same money, and you have tripled your exposure to execution error, feed problems and your own fatigue to get there. The arithmetic does not say trade less because activity is bad. It says each round trip must earn its ₹78, and most do not.

This is also the honest answer to why high-frequency retail scalping so rarely works. It is not that the edge is impossible to find. It is that at retail size the cost per round trip is ₹78 and the edge available on a three-point move, after the spread, is a few tens of rupees. The strategy is not wrong. The denominator is.

What to take from this chapter

  • Assemble one number: statutory plus spread, per unit, per round trip. For a 75-unit ATM weekly that is about ₹1.04.
  • Costs do not shave your profit, they raise your required hit rate. Break-even hit rate = (avg loss + cost) ÷ (avg win + avg loss).
  • On a three-point edge, a ₹1.04 cost moves break-even from 50% to 67%. That is a bigger gap than better rules usually close.
  • Compute cost ÷ average win for every strategy. Over a third and you are trading to pay fees.
  • The levers, in order: capture a bigger move, trade fewer and larger, remove orders. A cheaper broker is barely on the list.
  • Turn the cost into a daily budget. Every round trip has to earn its own fee, and most do not.