MyAlgoGuru Help
Education Glossary Open the app
Chapter 5 of 5

Choosing a strike, and the cheap-option trap

Pick the strike on probability and liquidity. Picking it on premium is how traders end up holding the one contract they cannot get out of.

Two traders want the same view expressed. One asks "which strike has the best risk-reward?" The other asks "which strike can I afford?"

The second question has an easy answer and it is almost always the wrong strike, for a reason that has nothing to do with the greeks.

Start with delta, not with premium

Delta is the cleanest strike selector available, because it is approximately the market's own estimate of the probability the option finishes in the money. That turns strike selection into a question you can actually answer.

Roughly Behaves like Typically used for
0.70 and above the underlying, with leverage a directional view you are confident in
0.45 to 0.55 balanced — most gamma, most vega a directional view over days
0.25 to 0.35 a cheap directional bet, or a sensible short the usual compromise strike
0.10 to 0.20 a lottery ticket, or a far short strike selling, with the caveats below
below 0.10 mostly a liquidity problem very little, honestly

Choosing by delta also makes your positions comparable across instruments and across weeks. "I buy the 0.35 delta" is a repeatable rule whose risk is roughly stable. "I buy the option costing about forty rupees" is not a rule at all — forty rupees is a different distance from the money every week, depending on volatility.

A strike scanner that filters by delta range, rather than by strike number, is the tool that makes this practical. The question you want to ask the chain is "show me the strikes between 0.25 and 0.35 delta", not "show me the 24,600".

Then check whether you can actually trade it

Here is the part that gets skipped, and it is the one that costs real money.

From the costs module: slippage expressed as a fraction of premium explodes as the premium shrinks, because the premium is the denominator. The same ₹0.20 spread is trivial on an expensive option and enormous on a cheap one.

The spread you cross, as a share of the premium you put up at the money — ₹120 0.08% one strike out — ₹78 0.13% two strikes out — ₹46 0.33% three strikes out — ₹24 0.63% four strikes out — ₹9 2.2% five strikes out — ₹2.50 8.0% The absolute spread barely doubles across these rows. Its share of your premium grows a hundredfold.
The cheap strike is the expensive one. Walking out from the money, the quoted spread widens only modestly in rupees — ₹0.10 becomes ₹0.20. But the premium falls from ₹120 to ₹2.50, so the spread as a share of what you are risking goes from 0.08% to 8%. The five-strikes-out option looks like the affordable choice and hands eight percent of its value to the market maker on the round trip, before brokerage, before STT, and before the market has moved at all.

Put that beside the figure from the costs module — roughly 0.79% in statutory charges on a round trip — and the far strike's problem is clear. A strategy targeting a 20% return on premium at five strikes out is handing over 8% to the spread and 0.8% to charges: nearly 45% of the gross objective, consumed by friction.

The four questions to ask before you trade a strike

Fast, and they filter out nearly every bad choice:

Is there a two-sided quote? Both a bid and an ask, right now. If one side is missing, you have no idea what the exit costs.

What is the spread as a percentage of the premium? Compute it. Under 1% is comfortable, 1–3% needs a reason, over 5% means you are trading the spread rather than the view.

Has it traded today? Open interest tells you what was built up over previous sessions. Today's volume tells you whether anybody is there now. A strike with high open interest and no volume today is a crowd that has already gone home.

Is the price I am looking at a price? A last-traded value from an hour ago is a historical fact, not a quote. On a strike that has not traded, the honest valuation comes from the midpoint of a live bid and ask — and if there is no two-sided quote, the honest answer is that the strike has no price at all.

That final question deserves emphasis because of how the failure looks. A chain cell showing 0 does not mean the option is worth nothing. It means nothing was measured. Software that passes that zero downstream will compute a premium, a delta, an implied volatility and a payoff diagram from it, all of which will look exactly as authoritative as the real ones. Any strategy built on an untraded strike's zero is built on an absence formatted as a number.

The cheap-option illusion

Why the far strike is so persistently attractive is worth naming, because knowing the mechanism is most of the defence.

A ₹2.50 option offers an enormous multiple if it works. Twenty-to-one outcomes exist there, they get talked about, and the loss when it does not work is only ₹2.50 — which feels bounded and therefore safe.

What the story leaves out:

  • The probability is in the price. A 0.05-delta option is priced as a one-in-twenty chance because that is roughly what it is. The twenty-to-one payoff is not generosity, it is arithmetic.
  • Friction takes a huge share. 8% to the spread on a round trip, on an instrument whose entire thesis is a large multiple, is a material reduction in an already thin expectancy.
  • You often cannot exit at a profit. The option moves from ₹2.50 to ₹6 and you want out. The book at ₹6 might be a handful of units. The gain exists on screen and not necessarily in your account.
  • Selling them is worse than it looks. The far short strike is the one with the 8% spread, the thinnest book, and the biggest gap risk — and it is the leg most likely to be unfillable when you need to close it. The chapter on per-leg risk is about exactly this leg.

None of which makes far strikes untradeable. It makes them a position you take knowing the friction, at a size the liquidity supports, with an exit plan that does not assume a buyer will be there.

A default worth having

If you want one rule to start from and refine with experience: express directional views around 0.30 to 0.40 delta, and sell around 0.15 to 0.25 delta, and in both cases walk in from the strike you first wanted until the spread is under about 1% of premium.

That last clause is the one doing the work. It will frequently move you one or two strikes closer to the money than your instinct suggested, giving you a more expensive option with a materially better chance of being exitable at a price resembling what you see on screen.

Paying more premium for a strike you can actually get out of is not a compromise. It is the trade.

What to take from this chapter

  • Choose strikes by delta, which makes your rule repeatable and your risk comparable week to week. "The forty-rupee option" is not a rule.
  • Then check liquidity, because the spread as a share of premium explodes as the premium shrinks — 0.08% at the money, 8% five strikes out.
  • Four checks: a two-sided quote, the spread as a percentage of premium, volume today, and whether the number you see is a price at all.
  • High open interest with no volume today is a crowd that has already left.
  • A chain showing zero is a missing measurement, not a value. Everything computed from it looks just as precise as the real thing.
  • The cheap option's payoff multiple is arithmetic, not generosity — and friction takes a large share of an already thin expectancy.
  • Default to 0.30–0.40 delta for directional views and 0.15–0.25 for selling, then walk in until the spread is under about 1% of premium.