MyAlgoGuru Help
Education Glossary Open the app
Chapter 1 of 5

Why you were right and still lost money

An option's price has three drivers pulling in different directions. Until you can attribute a day's P&L to each of them, option results will feel arbitrary.

This is the experience that sends traders looking for an explanation.

You buy a call. The index goes up. You lose money.

Nothing has malfunctioned. An option's price is driven by three things at once, and on that particular day two of them went against you harder than the first one went for you. Until you can take a day's result apart and say which driver did what, options will keep producing outcomes that feel like they violate the rules — and you will keep drawing the wrong lessons from them.

Two parts, three drivers

An option's price splits into two parts:

Intrinsic value is what the option is worth if it expired right now. For a call, that is the underlying minus the strike, or zero if that is negative. It is arithmetic, with no opinion in it.

Extrinsic value — also called time value — is everything else. It is what the market charges for the possibility that the option ends up worth more. It can only decay to zero by expiry, and the whole difficulty of trading options lives here.

Those two parts are moved by three drivers:

Driver Moves the option because Measured by
The underlying moves intrinsic value changes, and the chance of finishing in the money changes delta
Time passes there is less remaining possibility to pay for theta
Expected volatility changes the market revises how much possibility is worth vega

A long option holder is paid by the first and charged by the second. The third can go either way, and it is the one that produces the surprises, because it is the only driver you cannot see on a price chart.

Taking a day apart

0 +₹8 delta index rose 0.4%, exactly as you expected −₹11 vega implied volatility fell three points after the event theta −₹4, one day less of possibility to sell −₹7 you were right about direction and still lost The view was correct. Two drivers you did not have a view on were larger than the one you did.
The same day, attributed. The direction call earned ₹8 — the trade worked. But the position was bought before an event, when implied volatility was elevated, and the event resolved: volatility fell three points and took ₹11 out of the price. A day of decay removed ₹4 more. Net, a correct view lost ₹7. Nothing here is unusual and nothing is unfair; the trader simply held a position with three exposures while having an opinion about one.

Attribution of this kind is the single most useful habit in options trading, and it needs no sophisticated tooling. At the end of a losing day, ask: how much of this was direction, how much was volatility, and how much was time? The answer changes what you do next.

  • Lost on direction? Your view was wrong. Ordinary; review the thesis.
  • Lost on volatility? Your timing was wrong relative to an event, not your view. Buy options when volatility is cheap, not when attention is high.
  • Lost on time? Your horizon was wrong. The move you expected needed to be faster, or the option needed to be longer-dated.

Three completely different lessons. A trader who only sees "lost ₹7 on a call while the index rose" learns none of them, and usually concludes that options are rigged.

Why buying before the event so often fails

The attribution above describes the most common losing trade in Indian options, and it is worth stating plainly because it looks so reasonable going in.

You expect a result, a policy announcement, a number. You buy an option to express it. You are right about the direction. You lose.

The reason is that everybody else also expected the event. The uncertainty was already in the price — that is what elevated implied volatility is — so you paid for the possibility in advance. When the event resolves, the uncertainty is gone whichever way it went, implied volatility collapses, and the option's extrinsic value goes with it. To profit, the underlying's move had to be larger than the move the market had already priced in. Being right was never enough; you had to be right by more than the consensus had allowed for.

This is not an argument against buying options before events. It is an argument for knowing what you are paying, so that you buy when the implied move is smaller than the move you expect, and not merely when you have a view.

The asymmetry between the two sides

One more thing follows from the three drivers, and it shapes almost every strategy decision you will make.

A long option is paid by movement and charged by time. Every day that passes costs you something, whether or not anything happens. You need the move, and you need it soon.

A short option is paid by time and charged by movement. Every quiet day earns you something. You need nothing to happen, and you need it to keep not happening.

That is why the two sides feel so different to trade. Long options lose slowly and reliably, and win occasionally and largely. Short options win slowly and reliably, and lose occasionally and largely. The expectancies can be similar; the experience is not, and the risk profiles are not remotely comparable — which the module on risk covered, and which the chapters ahead will keep returning to.

Most traders have a natural preference here, and it is worth knowing yours. Someone who cannot tolerate a slow bleed will abandon long options during a quiet fortnight. Someone who cannot tolerate a sudden large loss will abandon short options after their first bad gap. Both abandonments happen at the worst moment, and both are predictable from temperament before any money is committed.

What to take from this chapter

  • An option's price is intrinsic value plus extrinsic value, and all the difficulty lives in the extrinsic part.
  • Three drivers move it at once: the underlying (delta), time (theta) and expected volatility (vega).
  • You can be completely right about direction and lose, because you hold three exposures while having a view on one.
  • Attribute every losing day to direction, volatility or time. Each implies a different and incompatible lesson.
  • Buying before an event means paying for uncertainty in advance. To profit, the move must beat the move already priced in — not merely go your way.
  • Long options are paid by movement and charged by time; short options the reverse. Similar expectancy, completely different experience.
  • Know which of those two experiences you can actually sit through, before you have money in one.